Rich and buttery, this delicious batter with butter, sugar, ice cream, nutmeg, and cinnamon is a classic American drink. Served warm, it is a wonderful cocktail for winter. Hot Buttered Rum is a delicious mixture of butter, sugar, spices, and ice cream plus rum. Here is my Hot Buttered Rum Bread Pudding recipe which uses this Hot Buttered Rum Batter recipe. Ice cream makes this Hot Buttered Rum recipe from Zig Zag Café ultra-rich and creamy. So, now you can be in Hot Buttered Rum heaven with the drink and the dessert! hot buttered rum batter (see below) Tools: barspoon Glass: warm mug Garnish: dusting of ground cinnamon. Garnish this bad boy with whipped cream, nutmeg, and a cinnamon stick to maximize those warm and tingly drinking vibes. The ultimate hot buttered rum recipe for a cold night! And the nearly 20-year-old recipe still garners rave reviews from customers. Hot Buttered Rum is a soul warming winter cocktail! The Ultimate Hot Buttered Rum Recipe! boiling water 3 Tbsp. This recipe can be made in advance and stored in the freezer. On a chilly night, you won’t be sorry you have this batter on hand. This Hot Buttered Rum goes perfectly with fuzzy slippers, fireplaces and your favorite Christmas movie! Alright, without further adieu, let me tell you exactly how easy it is to make hot buttered rum mix! If you need a warm cocktail on a cold day you have to try out this Creamy Hot Buttered Rum.This tasty rum cocktail combines spiced rum, vanilla ice cream, cinnamon, and nutmeg, and basically tastes like somebody’s cuddling your mouth. This creamy, hot cocktail is made with spiced rum, cinnamon and ice cream to make it wonderfully decadent and delicious. rum 4 oz. 2 oz.