While the shower/tub has been popular for a long time, the latest trend in bathroom renovations is to do away with the combo and replace it with a freestanding tub and a separate glass panelled shower. Bath vs Shower – When It Comes to ROI, Which is Better? Showers don't take up as much room as a tub does, so in our older homes that get renovated, they usually go with an awesome shower and forgo the tub. For example, Deleting a fancy tub may save thousands of dollars – including installation – money that could be spent elsewhere. 2 bath or more - ideal for the master is separate tub and walk in shower; otherwise just a matter of preference (for some the lack of a tub will be a deal breaker but i would guess for most having a nice walk in shower would be a big plus). Many parents prefer to bathe children in a tub rather than a shower; many buyers like to soak in a tub. The master had a large tub. Its a deep plastic tub with an outside step. The house we sold had a tub in each bathroom. “Will not having a bathtub hurt my home’s resale value?” It is true that some families can’t live without a master bathtub, and by removing it you will exclude those families as potential buyers. If you have the space and the budget I say go for it, as you get the best of both worlds. In fact, in the high-end homes where they have separate master his and hers baths, his has a shower and hers has a spa tub. I did question the resale value in this home when I saw that it has just a walk in shower for the master bath. In 2017, he still claims, “As long as you have another bathtub in the house, ripping out the old jetted tub in the master should not hurt your resale value.” Dave maintains that oversized showers are still where it’s at, and he warns that deep jetted corner bathtubs can actually make a house … Admittedly, my husband and I are not "bath people" but we are glad for the tub in the 2nd bathroom since we have kids and dogs. I’m looking into doing a bathroom renovation. Rajeev Basu replaced the 1950s-era tub in his Greenwich Village co-op with a modern, marble-tiled shower. However, you have to keep in mind that any remodeling decision you make one way or another will always turn off one group of buyers. The question that many homeowners face is whether replacing a bathtub with a shower will affect the resale value of the home. It all comes down to how many bathrooms are in the home. In the majority of homes the shower gets used far more than the tub, and as a result there’s a trend towards getting rid of tubs completely and instead going for spacious, stand up shower stalls. The luxury home market—much thanks to high expectations of master bathrooms inspired by hotels and resorts—is obviously pricier. Showers don't take up as much room as a tub does, so in our older homes that get renovated, they usually go with an awesome shower and forgo the tub. 2 bed or more, with 1 bath - need a tub if you want to be able to sell to family The master bath has separate shower and tub areas. We have lots of master baths here that don't have tubs. Some Realtors we spoke to felt the lack of a tub in the master bathroom would hurt resale, others said buyers were shying away from homes that didn’t have an oversize shower, regardless of the presence of a tub. Eliminating a home's only full bathroom could turn off potential buyers. We never use the tub in the master bath. 2nd bath should have a tub.